Yes, it will usually be a permanent change to her contract but you can agree with your employee that it is a temporary change with an agreed review date. This will allow you and the employee to trial the arrangement to determine its suitability for both parties. The arrangement might then be retained or an alternative arrangement agreed.
Male employees who have worked for you for more that 26 weeks have a statutory right to ask for flexible working. You must treat the request in the same way as you would treat a request from a woman in similar circumstances. Failure to do so may be sex discrimination.
An employee must make a written, dated application setting out:
-
Proposed change to working conditions and date of change.
-
Effect of change on the employer and how to address perceived negative impacts and;
-
A statement that this is a statutory request and setting out any previous applications, with dates.
If the change is because of a disability, to care for a child or dependant or race, it is good practice to encourage the employee to say this, so it can be taken into account. This will help protect you against claims of indirect discrimination or failure to make a reasonable adjustment in particular.
You must:
-
Consider the benefits of the requested changes for the employee and the business, weighing the benefits against any adverse business impact.
-
Avoid both direct and indirect discrimination.
-
Discuss the request with the employee within the statutory timeframe, allowing them to be accompanied to a meeting by a work colleague or trade union official recognised by you as the employer, unless you have already agreed the request in which case a meeting may not be necessary.
-
Give a decision within the statutory timeframe and the decision should be in writing.
-
You must consider each request individually and with an open mind, following the requirements of the existing legislation.
It is good practice to make a decision as quickly as possible so that you and the employee can plan her return to work and the employee can find the right childcare for the days she will be working.
You can refuse a statutory flexible working request for one of the eight reasons set out in Article 112G
Employment Rights (NI) Order 1996. The grounds for refusal under the flexible working procedure are:
-
The burden of additional costs.
-
An inability to reorganise work amongst existing staff.
-
An inability to recruit additional staff.
-
A detrimental impact on quality.
-
A detrimental impact on performance.
-
A detrimental effect on ability to meet customer demand.
-
Insufficient work for the periods the employee proposes to work.
-
A planned structural change to the business.
If you refuse the request for flexible working without a good business reason this might be
indirect sex discrimination. To reduce the risk of complaints arising and increase your chances of successfully defending those that do arise, see the Equality Commission's
flexible working guide for employers (pdf)
Your employee may make a claim against you for:
-
Failure to consider the flexible working application in a reasonable manner.
-
Failure to notify the employee of a decision within three months.
-
Refusing the application without a specified business reason.
An industrial tribunal may order you to reconsider the employee’s application or make an award of compensation up to a maximum of eight weeks’ pay.